Hypertrophic Scars: Causes, Risk Factors, and Treatment Options
1. What Are Hypertrophic Scars?
Definition
Hypertrophic scars are a type of abnormal wound healing where the scar tissue becomes raised, thickened, and remains within the boundaries of the original injury. They are a result of excessive collagen production during the healing process. Unlike keloid scars, which grow beyond the wound's edges, hypertrophic scars stay confined but can still be uncomfortable and unsightly.
Appearance and Symptoms
Typically, hypertrophic scars appear red or pink initially and may become darker over time. They are firm to the touch, raised above the skin level, can feel tight, and can cause symptoms such as itching, heat intolerance, tenderness, or even pain in some cases.
Common Locations
These scars are more likely to develop in areas where the skin experiences tension or frequent movement, such as:
Chest and Shoulders: Due to the natural stretch and pull of the skin.
Joints (e.g., elbows and knees): Frequent bending and extension increase stress on wounds.
Neckline: Scars in this area are often visible, aesthetically, and functionally concerning for patients.
2. How Do Hypertrophic Scars Form?
Wound healing is a dynamic and intricate biological process, generally unfolding across three primary stages. However, in hypertrophic scars, there's often a disruption in this balance, with an overproduction of collagen.
Inflammation: This initial stage involves the removal of damaged tissue and combating infection. It sets the stage for subsequent healing phases.
Proliferation: During this phase, fibroblasts synthesise new collagen fibers to replace the damaged tissue, essential for wound closure.
Remodelling: The final phase involves the restructuring and refinement of collagen, shaping the mature scar tissue.
Hypertrophic scars arise when there is an excessive collagen deposition during the proliferation stage, which isn't sufficiently broken down or remodeled, leading to raised and often rigid scar formations.
Underlying Mechanisms
Hypertrophic scars arise from several key abnormalities in the healing process:
- Overactive Fibroblasts: These cells are integral to collagen production. In the case of hypertrophic scars, fibroblasts are overactive, leading to the production of an excessive amount of collagen, which thickens and raises the scar.
- Delayed Collagen Breakdown: Normally, enzymes efficiently degrade excess collagen during the remodeling phase of healing. However, in hypertrophic scars, this breakdown is delayed or inefficient, resulting in an accumulation of collagen.
- Excessive Wound Contraction: This occurs when the scar margins pull inward more aggressively than usual during healing, leading to a tight, puckered appearance. While excessive contraction may contribute to tension, it is not the sole source of it.
- Tension on the Wound: Tension can be an independent factor affecting scar formation, arising from external or internal forces that stretch or pull on the wound area. This includes skin tightness, nearby muscle movements, or even certain postures or activities. Such tension does not necessarily stem from the contraction of the scar itself. Instead, it can independently exacerbate the inflammatory response and stimulate further collagen production, thereby influencing the development of hypertrophic scars.
3. Which Skin Types Are Prone to Hypertrophic Scars?
Genetic and Skin Type Influences
Certain skin types have a greater propensity for developing hypertrophic scars, which is largely influenced by genetic factors and the inherent characteristics of the skin:
Darker Skin Tones (Fitzpatrick IV–VI): Higher levels of melanin production correlate with increased fibroblast activity and collagen deposition, making darker skin more prone to hypertrophic scarring. This heightened biological activity makes darker skin more susceptible to hypertrophic scarring.
Very Fair Skin (Fitzpatrick Type I): While generally less common than in darker skin tones, individuals with Type I skin can be particularly prone to pathological scarring, especially in cases of severe trauma such as burns or invasive surgeries. This susceptibility may be due to an intense inflammatory response and a distinct healing process characteristic of very fair skin.
Age and Gender
Age: The risk of developing hypertrophic scars is higher among younger individuals, typically between 10 and 30 years old, due to their more vigorous collagen production, which can lead to an excessive healing response.
Gender: While no definitive gender link exists, some studies suggest hormonal fluctuations, particularly during puberty or pregnancy, may influence scar formation.
4. Factors That Influence Hypertrophic Scar Formation
Injury Characteristics
Depth and Severity of the Wound: Deeper injuries stimulate more collagen production during the healing process, increasing the likelihood of hypertrophic scarring.
Delayed Healing: Wounds that take longer than three weeks to close (due to infection, poor circulation, or other factors) are more prone to abnormal scarring.
Burns: These injuries are particularly problematic as they cause widespread inflammation, a key trigger for hypertrophic scars.
Location of the Scar
Scars in high-tension areas such as the chest, shoulders, or joints experience more mechanical stress during healing, promoting abnormal collagen deposition.
Environmental Factors
Infections: Wounds that become infected are more likely to heal poorly, increasing the risk of hypertrophic scarring.
UV Exposure: Ultraviolet light can darken scars and exacerbate pigmentation issues, especially in darker skin tones.
Medical Conditions and Lifestyle Factors Affecting Wound Healing
Certain medical conditions and lifestyle choices do not directly cause hypertrophic scarring but can significantly impact the overall healing process, potentially influencing the quality of the resulting scar:
Chronic Conditions: Conditions like diabetes, autoimmune disorders, and poor circulation can impair the body’s ability to heal wounds effectively. These impairments can lead to prolonged inflammation or delayed healing, which in some cases might contribute indirectly to abnormal scar formation, such as hypertrophic scars.
Smoking and Nutrition: Smoking decreases the oxygen supply to healing tissues, critical for effective wound repair, while poor nutrition can deprive the body of essential nutrients necessary for healing, such as vitamin C and zinc. Although these factors do not directly cause hypertrophic scarring, they can result in poorer healing outcomes and may affect the severity or the appearance of scars due to compromised tissue repair processes.
Understanding these connections can help in managing the risk factors for complicated healing and in implementing strategies to improve wound care and outcomes.
5. Treatment Options for Hypertrophic Scars
A. Non-Invasive Treatments
Silicone Products:
Silicone gels, tapes, and sheets create a protective barrier that hydrates the scar tissue, softening and flattening it.
Sheets and tapes also apply mild compression, which helps reduce scar thickness over time.
Compression Therapy:
Compression therapy is commonly used for burn scars and is also effective for managing other types of scars. By applying continuous pressure, compression garments help to reduce collagen production and improve the texture of the scar, making them beneficial for hypertrophic scars and post-surgical healing.
Topical Treatments:
Corticosteroid creams reduce inflammation and scar height.
Compounded Topical Treatments:
- Customised creams can combine corticosteroids with other active ingredients like hydroquinone and other medications for pigmentation and retinoids for skin texture improvement.
- Other Effective Agents: Additional agents that can be incorporated into compounded formulations include vitamin E or onion extract, which may help in reducing redness and promoting smoother skin, though their effectiveness can vary among individuals.
B. Minimally Invasive Treatments
Corticosteroid Infiltrations (injected or laser assisted delivery):
These infiltrations are directly administered into the scar to reduce inflammation and slow collagen production.
Laser-assisted delivery enhances penetration for more stubborn scars.
Laser Therapy:
Vascular Lasers: Target redness by reducing blood vessels within the scar.
Fractional Ablative Lasers: Resurface the scar and stimulate normal collagen remodelling. These are often combined with laser-assisted drug delivery techniques using steroids or 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) to improve results.
C. Surgical Options
Scar Revision Surgery:
Surgical scar revisoin primarily focuses on releasing tension to improve both the appearance and comfort of scars, utilising a diverse range of approaches.
Evidence strongly supports that combining surgical scar revision with other treatment modalities can enhance effectiveness.
Additionally, initiating these combined treatments early in the scar maturation process significantly improves outcomes, leading to more favorable results.
6. Tips for Preventing Hypertrophic Scars
Adequate Wound Care
Proper care during the early stages of healing is crucial:
Clean the wound regularly to prevent infections.
Use suitable dressings that support a good healing environment, which is crucial for optimal scar formation. The type of dressing should be tailored to the specific needs of the wound.
Sun Protection
Apply sunscreen and physical cover healing scars to prevent sunburn and hyperpigmentation.
Silicone products with built-in UV protection are available for added convenience.
Monitoring Healing
Early detection of abnormal scar formation allows for timely intervention.
Signs such as raised, red tissue or delayed healing warrant consultation with a specialist.
Post-Injury Support
For individuals at high risk of developing pathological scarring, early use of compression garments and silicone products is crucial. This is especially important for burn victims or those with a previous history of such scarring, as these interventions can significantly manage and minimise scar development.
Photomodulation: Recent research suggests that early intervention using photomodulating techniques significantly improves overall outcomes by promoting faster and more effective healing processes.
Conclusion
Hypertrophic scars are a common challenge for individuals recovering from injuries or surgeries. By understanding how they form and recognising the risk factors, patients can take proactive steps to minimise their impact. A range of effective treatments, from silicone sheets to advanced laser therapies and surgery, is available to help manage these scars.
For the best outcomes, consult with a specialist who can tailor a treatment plan to your unique needs. Whether you’re seeking prevention or intervention, there are solutions available to help you restore confidence and comfort.
Need Support for Scar Management?
Our clinic offers expert care for hypertrophic scars with state-of-the-art treatments tailored to your skin type. Contact us today for a personalised consultation! Call us at +61 2 9037 6306